Welcome to the final installment of our series on the Employment-Based Second Preference National Interest Waiver (EB2 NIW) Green Card category. In our previous articles, we discussed the EB-2 threshold requirements, how to demonstrate substantial merit and national importance, how to prove that you are well-positioned to advance your proposed endeavor, and the importance of linking your past successes with future plans. Today, we’ll focus on the third and final prong of the Matter of Dhanasar test: proving that it is in the national interest to waive the job offer and labor certification requirements.
Understanding the Third Prong: Waiving the Job Offer and Labor Certification Requirements
The third prong of the Matter of Dhanasar test is where you make the case that the work you intend to do is so important that the U.S. should allow you to pursue it without the traditional constraints that apply to most employment-based immigrant petitions. This is relevant for a wide range of professionals, including those in research, technology, healthcare, and more. However, it is especially critical for entrepreneurs, who face unique challenges in the labor certification process.
Key Factors to Consider
The Nature of Your Work
Significance of Your Work: Whether you are a researcher, a healthcare professional, or an entrepreneur, the work you plan to do in the U.S. must be of such significance that it justifies bypassing the usual labor market protections. This often involves showing that your work addresses a critical public need or advances a significant national interest.
Example: If your work involves developing cutting-edge renewable energy technology or creating a healthcare solution to a public health crisis, you could argue that your contributions are too valuable to be delayed by the job offer and labor certification process.
Impracticality of Obtaining Labor Certification
General Challenges: For many professionals, obtaining a job offer or labor certification can be challenging, especially if their work is highly specialized or time-sensitive. For entrepreneurs, this challenge is even more pronounced because the labor certification process is designed to protect U.S. workers, making self-sponsorship impossible if you own a majority share in your U.S.-based company.
Example: If your proposed endeavor is time-sensitive or if you are an entrepreneur whose business would be impeded by the labor certification process, you can argue that it is impractical and against the national interest to require you to undergo this process.
Public Benefit and Urgency
Broad Benefits: Whether you are advancing scientific research, developing new technology, or launching a business, it is crucial to emphasize the broader public benefits of your work and the urgency with which these benefits need to be realized.
Example: If your work is expected to generate significant economic growth, create jobs, or lead to major technological or healthcare advancements, these factors can bolster your argument that it’s in the national interest to allow you to proceed without a job offer and labor certification.
Uniqueness of Your Contributions
Specialized Expertise: USCIS will look for evidence that you offer something unique that would be difficult to replicate through the hiring of U.S. workers. This could involve demonstrating that your specific skills, knowledge, or experience are not readily available in the U.S. labor market. For entrepreneurs, this might mean showing that your innovative vision and leadership are integral to your business's success.
Example: If you have specialized expertise in a niche area that is critical to your field or to the success of your business, you could argue that your contributions are irreplaceable.
Supporting Evidence
Validation from Authorities: Supporting evidence can include letters from government agencies, industry experts, or organizations that underscore the importance of your work.
Example: A letter from a federal or state agency stating that your work aligns with national policy goals or addresses a critical national need can be particularly persuasive.
Balancing the Argument
When making your case for the third prong, it’s important to balance several key arguments:
Demonstrate the Impact: Clearly articulate how your work will benefit the U.S. and why it’s critical to waive the job offer and labor certification requirements.
Highlight Urgency: Show that your work is time-sensitive and that any delays could result in missed opportunities for significant advancements or public benefits.
Emphasize Uniqueness: Prove that you bring unique skills, knowledge, or expertise that cannot be easily found in the U.S. labor market, justifying the waiver.
How to Present Your Evidence
To effectively present your case, follow these guidelines:
Narrative Structure: Start with a clear statement of your proposed work and why it is in the national interest, followed by an explanation of how the labor certification process would impede your efforts.
Use Strong Evidence: Include supporting letters from reputable sources, such as government officials, industry leaders, or academic experts, who can attest to the significance of your work.
Tie Back to Previous Prongs: Make connections to the evidence and arguments from the first two prongs to create a cohesive and compelling overall case.
Conclusion
The third prong of the Matter of Dhanasar test is crucial to securing an EB2 NIW Green Card. By demonstrating that your work—whether in research, technology, healthcare, or entrepreneurship—is of such importance that it justifies bypassing the labor certification process, and by providing strong, evidence-backed arguments, you can make a compelling case for why granting you this waiver is in the best interest of the United States.
This concludes our series on the EB2 NIW Green Card process. We hope these articles have provided valuable insights and guidance for navigating the requirements and successfully advancing your case.
If you're considering applying for the EB2 NIW or want personalized guidance on your immigration journey, reach out to us at info@peludimmigration.com to schedule a personal consultation. We're here to help you navigate the process and strengthen your petition for success.
Comments